Latest Howard Marks Memo: 'Touchstones' (November 2009)
Once again, Oaktree Capital Management's Howard Marks has some lucid commentary on achieving investment success in an imperfect world:
In the two-plus years since the onset of the financial crisis, it’s been a regular theme of mine that we should look back, identify the causes and learn from them. I’ve tackled this assignment in a number of memos and a variety of ways. Now, despite the fact that you’ve heard much of this from me before, I’m going to try to pull it all together, using the quotations, adages and images that I feel best capture the essence of what we’ve been through. When I think back, these are the ones that stand out.
"Greed Is Good"
There’s no debating which line from the film Wall Street is the most memorable. It’s hard to forget the image of slicked-back takeover artist Gordon Gekko urging on his troops, invoking the positive power of self-interest. What he meant by “greed is good,” of course, was that greed – or self-interest, or the profit motive – is what drives people and companies operating in a freemarket setting to strive for more and better, and thus to work hard and optimally allocate resources. It’s the force that motivates Adam Smith’s “invisible hand” and carries economies to increased output and higher standards of living.
Among the many pendulum-like phenomena we occasionally witness is the swing in people’s willingness to rely on the free market. First they trust the market to come up with solutions. Then the shortcomings of those solutions are laid bare and there’s a call for regulation. Then the folly of government involvement becomes evident and people want the free market back, and so forth. Because neither extreme is perfect, the oscillation between them goes on. Governments can’t run economies or companies. But it’s equally true that in a free market, the rules will occasionally be stretched and participants harmed.
In a free market, things will inevitably go past the optimal to the extreme. When they swing back, the retreat can be painful. Thus, if we’re going to rely on the market to settle things, we have to be willing to accept the consequences.